OSO, WA (AP) — The Washington state Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court ruling that shields Snohomish County from lawsuits seeking damages related to the 2014 landslide in Oso.

The same case two years ago resulted in a $60 million settlement for slide survivors and representatives for some of the 43 people killed in the disaster.

The state and a private timber company paid the settlement after plaintiffs’ attorneys discovered that some attorneys from the other side had systematically destroyed documents that should have been shared before trial.

The judge, by that time, had already excluded the county from the case. The plaintiffs appealed.

The three-judge panel wrote that they found no basis for holding the county liable in the disaster.